Mar | 23
(5)
Running Tips

The Breakdown: Pavement vs. Trail Running

There is a lot of discussion around pavement vs. trail running, but for some runners it’s nice to have a mix of both. We reached out to the expert, Danny Mackey, coach of the Brooks Beasts for his insights into the pros and cons for both types of running.

Pavement Running 

P72_SR100484_Brooks-04723

Pros:

– The surface is more “known” so you do not have to worry about ankle sprains or tweaks as much on the pavement.  Leading into a big race if you have the option of pavement or a trail,  go pavement to reduce any last minute, sneaky injuries.

– Pavement has a higher friction dynamic then soft surface.  So if you are dealing with soft tissues issues (like achilles) run on the bike path versus the soft dirt or gravel so you are not slipping at toe off, or at contact.

– If you are trying to run fast on the track or roads, pavement is more specific to your race surface. Ground reaction forces are high on pavement so there may be workouts where you want to mimic these forces to help your body learn how to manage and adapt to get stronger.

Cons: 

– The pavement does not compress below your foot and with 2-3 times your body weight coming down with each step this increases the chance of stress related injuries to the muscular-skeletal system.

– Pavement typically means city running, which means cars and curbs. Safety becomes a top priority to ensure that you are following traffic regulations and being aware of what is going on around you. You would not want to step off a curb and injury yourself because you were not paying attention.

Trail Running

P72_SR100484_Brooks-02586

Pros:

– Having an “unknown” surface is great for  strengthening the intrinsic muscles in the foot and the stabilizing muscles in the lower leg.  Running is chronic and having a unique landing surface with each step can help prevent some overuse injuries.

-Dirt has lower ground reaction forces than hard surfaces, which can help prevent bones injuries.

– Beautiful scenery!  There is something special about being in different environments and running in nature.

Cons: 

– Chronic injuries show up on the roads but the one time, out of your control acute injuries (such as a sprained ankle)  come from the trail.

– Lack of conversation. Most trails require runners to pay attention to the ground and trails are typically single file so you cannot run next to your fellow training partner.  What you gain in scenery you might lose in good conversations with a friend or training buddy.

Which surface do you prefer to run on? Pavement, trail or a mix of both? We want to know, comment below or tweet us @brooksrunning.

About Melissa
In my past life, I was a collegiate runner. Now, I happily run in Brooks Ravennas or Ghosts. If all my running shoes were turquoise in color, I would not complain.
5 Comments
  • Julie

    I’m more a pavement runner since I’ve already ruptured one Achilles and have tendonitis in the other.

  • Love love love road for the meditative element (getting in the “zone”), but have been dabbling in trails for cross training, and a massive challenge to the quads (especially in the PacNW/local Vancouver Mountains).

  • julie

    Love trail running.like the fact that vehicles aren’t buzzing by.I feel my best when done.

  • Christopher

    While I am a trail/ultra runner, I like to experience all types of running so I break up my training between pavement and trail.
    This gives me the best of both worlds and keeps my body from becoming accustomed to just one type of running.

  • Coach

    I tripped on a curb that I run all the time last month. Thankfully, I tucked and rolled, only soiling, NOT RIPPING, my new Brooks windbreaker! If you haven’t tried good-ole childhood tumbling in a long time, try it in the soft grass and plan to use it if you go down when running Guide yourself with your arms. I think I prevented a nasty, injurious fall that day.